Applied Philosophy Online .com 

Where Ideas Are Brought Down to Earth!

Writings based on Objectivism, the philosophy of Ayn Rand

Ayn Rand's most popular novels are Atlas Shrugged and The Fountainhead which present her philosophy, Objectivism, in vivid characterizations. Metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, esthetics, and  politics are the five main branches of philosophy that she identifies. Utilizing her methodology, one can be rational about all aspects of life. These essays present my understanding of Objectivism.

Home
Up

Independence Day Special 2005

Copyright Issues Statement

 

Date: Fri, 01 Jun 2001 
Christianity and Volition
Thomas M. Miovas, Jr.


><HB: (quoting Aristotle)
>"And further the possession of knowledge in another sense
>than those just named is something that happens to men;
>for within the case of having knowledge but not using it
>we see a difference of state, admitting of the possibility
>of having knowledge in a sense and yet not having it, as
>in the instance of a man asleep, mad, or drunk....It is
>plain, then, that incontinent people must be said to be
>in a similar condition to men asleep, mad, or drunk.>


In the previous passage, Aristotle seems to be getting close to 
understanding volition, at least implicitly, as Harry indicated (having 
knowledge and exercising it or not exercising it); but notice in the 
passage above that Aristotle seems to think it is *inconceivable* that a 
man can freely act against his own knowledge -- saying, in effect, that 
this can happen only if a man is "asleep, mad, or drunk." Clearly Aristotle 
does not understand that one's volition can override one's knowledge -- 
i.e. that volition is more fundamental to human consciousness than 
knowledge. Both the Ancient Greeks and the Ancient Romans (prior to the 
widespread acceptance of Christianity) thought that if a man had knowledge 
of right and wrong, he would *have* to follow that knowledge -- unless he 
was asleep, mad, or drunk -- almost as a form of determinism.

<HB: No, I think this is a misreading of the passage. He is observing, by 
reference to extreme cases, that people can "know" better than what they 
do--by not exercising their knowledge.<snip>>

I have to give credit to the acceptance of volition as a fundamental aspect 
of human consciousness to Augustine, especially in his book _The City of 
God_, which was written well before the Dark Ages set in. One can certainly 
say that Augustine and Plotinus via Plato brought about the Dark Ages, but 
a crucially important understanding of the nature of human consciousness 
was made prior to that time period. Ironically, this insight was brought 
about due to a fundamental contradiction between early Christianity (which 
Augustine was converted to from a form of materialism) and the nature of 
reality -- or the relationship between morality and reality and the fact 
that Christian morality is not based on reality.

<HB: Augustine is contradictory. He is very deterministic in many of his 
writings.>

Christianity is not a moral code that can be practiced consistently, 
because it is incompatible with human nature and reality, but this is 
precisely what gave rise to Augusine's moral qualms that he relates in _The 
City of God_. He continually claims that he has knowledge of good and evil, 
yet he can not seem to practice the good -- i.e. "God grant me chastity, 
but not just yet!" Because he believes he understands what God wants him to 
do and what kind of life he should lead and yet does not practice it, he 
realizes there is something missing from the formulation of the idea of the 
incontinent man that was handed down from the Greeks and the Romans. That 
missing element is **willfully** accepting the edicts of God -- i.e. 
volitionally accepting to act according to one's chosen moral code.

Now, because Christianity's moral base was mystical (not based on fact), 
willfully accepting God's edicts meant acting against reality -- which is 
what brought about the Dark Ages. Nonetheless, as far as I know, this 
formulation of freely and willfully accepting and practicing a moral code 
is the first time in history anyone brought the issue up explicitly.

[Tom Miovas: I think in this thread, someone made the off-hand comment that
since I was raised Catholic, I could be forgiven for having the view that
Augustine (or Christians) were the first ones to have an explicit view
of voliton. I insert this comment just in case anyone out there thinks
Objectivists don't have a sense of humor ;)]

<HB: Some other good quotes from Aristotle:

"A man is said to have or not to have self-control according as his reason 
has or has not the control, on the assumption that this <i.e., reason> is 
the man himself; and the things men have done on a rational principle are 
thought most properly their own acts and voluntary acts." Bk IX, Ch. 8.

"The origin of action--its efficient, not its final cause--is choice, and 
that of choice is desire and reasoning with a view to an end. This is why 
choice cannot exist either without reason and intellect or without a moral 
state..." Bk VI, Ch. 2

"... man is a moving principle or begetter of his actions as of children." 
BK III, Ch. 5.>


Computers4SURE's Best Deals

FREE 2nd Day FedEx Shipping!

LastMinuteTravel.com

Magazineline

Great Deals at Overstock.com

Personal Creations - Clearance Sale - Up to 80% Off!

Get your motor running!

LinkShare Corporation

BuyersGoingCrazy

Need a poem or a short story written for a special occasion or to commemorate one?

Drop me a line and we can talk terms!

Click here for examples

Be sure to check out the essays dedicated to applying Objectivism

to a wide variety of topics

And view the great artists presented

in the art prints section

All rights reserved, entire contents of web site.

Thomas M. Miovas, Jr.

tmiovas@appliedphilosophyonline.com

disclaimers

Banner 10001202

Lightwedge Reading Light

Banner 10000166

Banner 10000031